These are some of the ideas I've found online and am mentally trying to modify to fit my needs.
These spider legs are held inside with peanut butter, but I think that's a risky move with so many peanut allergy sufferers these days (I guess that means I have a 3rd parameter to work around). Maybe cream cheese or spreadable cheese would work, but would the kids want to eat like 50 of them? There are 26 kids in the class.
I was thinking that the marshmallow head part of this might be fun for them to make and then eat (no cupcake) but would that be lame? I should probably check with Whitney. I have 15 minutes for the Treat Rotation, so this would keep them busy.

I think this googly eye is rather funny, but how could I do it without the cupcake?

Would something like this be too boring? I'd probably need a ton of it, plus what would we do while we ate it? It won't take 15 minutes to eat a handful of this.
I am very well-intentioned and good natured about these class parties, but I find myself severely idea challenged so I need YOU! I'm open to pretty much anything that fits into my parameters so please give me your ideas.
Comment Window Tidbit: I'm freezing!